|Season 2, Episode 12|
January 25, 2009
Justin casts Harper as Tinker Bell when he directs a school production of "Peter Pan", but Alex must play the role when Harper falls off the stage. Alex tries to escape out of her duty by attempting to throw herself off the stage like Harper but fails. She then gets the help of a real fairy called Flutter to play her part, but she gets busted. Meanwhile, Max tries to write a review of the play.
- This episode is later seen as a flashback in Who will be the Family Wizard?